Re: [IP] Re: Type 2 NOT caused by obesity...
Probably the best explanation I've seen is a quote from Ruth Kava of the
American Council of Science and Health, who said, "Genetics loads the gun and
environment pulls the trigger." So. If the gun isn't loaded, it doesn't matter
if you pull the trigger or not -- nothing is going to happen.. :-)
Also, do a search for Vincent Poitout, who is a lead researcher on type 2 and
obesity. He has been quoted as saying, "Obesity itself doesn't cause
diabetes," and explains that scientists now believe a combination of genetic
environmental factors determine who gets type 2 diabetes.
And I will also repeat what I said a week or so ago about results of the DPP,
which the media said "proved" type 2 could be prevented: The people in the
study had personal trainers, they had nutritionally balanced meals delivered to
them, there was a high dropout rate and a percentage of the participants STILL
got type 2 diabetes. It CANNOT always be prevented.
I also believe that type 2 has always been present in children ... it's just
that nobody started looking for it until about 20 years ago. Yep. 20 years
ago. And it's just been in the news for a couple years or so. Of course "they"
are looking for it now -- and they're finding it, too. Big surprise! (NOT!)
Jan and ElvisToo
In a message dated 9/7/03 2:14:01 PM US Eastern Standard Time,
email @ redacted writes:
> "Ryan Bruner" <email @ redacted> wrote:
> What this indicates is that obesity doesn't CAUSE Type 2 diabetes in any
> way...but rather, that the genetics that lead to the development of Type 2
> diabetes ALSO make people prone to obesity.<<
> What are your sources for these studies? How do you explain
> overweight children/teens who are now developing Type 2 diabetes
> which was something that was unheard years ago before video game
> systems and computers? The genes were the same then as they are now.
> Being overweight HAS to be a major contributing factor in these
> cases. These kids weren't thin or average in weight and THEN
> developed Type 2 and THEN gained the weight. The weight was there
> from the get-go and was the main contributor to their diagnosis of
> Type 2. Many Type 2's lose weight and lose their diabetes...so
> weight DOES matter and in many cases can be the ONE thing that
> determines whether you have it or not.
for HELP or to subscribe/unsubscribe, contact: