[Previous Months][Date Index][Thread Index][Join - Register][Login]
[Message Prev][Message Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Re: [IP] Accu-Chek Complete vs. OneTouch Profile(some questions)
Hey guys...I did a check myself and found that my accuchek advantage was 22
mg/dl higher consistently than my profile...but it was CONSISTENT so I did
the same thing that Dan did and just changed my target range...I like the
profile better but that's just personal preference and the fact that my
advantage seems to error out too much and I have to pay for the strips
myself! (insurance doesn't cover them YET until I actually go on the pump,
then they might have no CHOICE!)
At 12:46 AM 3/25/1998 -0500, Ted wrote:
>Dan Oliver wrote:
>> I did the same side-by-side with an Accu-Chek Advantage and a OneTouch
>> Profile some time ago (the Advantage and the Complete use the same strip,
>> and both use the same test electronics, according to Boehringer).
>> I found that the Advantage gave readings consistently around 10-11% higher
>> than the Profile. I had read somewhere at the time that the Advantage was
>> likely (in the U.S., anyway) tuned to more closely match the plasma readings
>> that labs produce. As I recall this equates to artificially increasing the
>> whole-blood result by multiplying it by 1.125.
>> That's pretty darn close to the difference that I saw empirically. The only
>> thing that I had to do as a result was to raise my BG target range by 12%.
>> The correlation between the two meters was very close during the entire
>> experiment (which is pretty amazing for home-testing devices). The only
>> significant difference was the aforementioned offset.
>> At 09:22 3/24/98 -0700, Kristine wrote:
>> >In 3 days worth of side-by-side testing from the same drop of blood,
>> >the Complete was consistently 6 to 10 mg/dl higher than the Profile.
>> > It was closer (6) in the hypo range and the error got bigger with
>> >larger bg's.
>> >Kristine L. Govertsen
>> Insulin-Pumpers website http://www.bizsystems.com/Diabetes/
> Dear Dan,
>Are saying that the profile isn't accurate? The accu-chek is a better way to
>go? I haven't used that one for about seven yrs. since I've been using the
>profile. Are the highs on the Profile not really high enough????
>Marilyn from Maryland
>Insulin-Pumpers website http://www.bizsystems.com/Diabetes/
Insulin-Pumpers website http://www.bizsystems.com/Diabetes/